News Department

Bombshell story proves Murphy Administration was warned nursing home order would result in outbreaks and deaths, Senator Pennacchio says

Nursing home administrator told Health Commissioner on recorded call: “Patients will die”

NEW JERSEY – Senator Joe Pennacchio said a bombshell news report proves without a doubt that the Murphy administration was warned by nursing home administrators last year that an order forcing them to accept COVID-positive patients would result in outbreaks and deaths in their facilities.

According to the story by Susan K. Livio and Ted Sherman on, nursing home administrators participated in a March 31, 2020 conference call with New Jersey Department of Health Commissioner Judith Persichilli where they expressed their dire concerns about a new directive forcing their facilities to accept patients from hospitals and prohibiting those patients for being tested for COVID-19 prior to admission.

“Nursing home administrators were crystal clear when they told Commissioner Persichilli they couldn’t safely admit COVID-19 patients without putting their other residents at risk,” Pennacchio (R-26) said. “They said COVID would spread through their facilities and people would die as a result of the dangerous order. Tragically, the Murphy administration ignored their prescient warnings and thousands of people died.”

According to, one administrator told Persichilli and Health Department officials on the recorded call, “Patients will die. You understand that by asking us to take COVID patients, by demanding we take COVID patients, that patients will die in nursing homes that wouldn’t have otherwise died had we screened them out.”

Another, doubting the commissioner’s suggestion that COVID patients and caregivers could be effectively cohorted in separate units, told her, “You have asked us to separate safely and create our own wing and take in COVID-19’s from the hospital. The problem, of course, is there is no separating safely. It’s almost certain that even though you have staff only on that unit, something will migrate.”

Pennacchio chaired an independent hearing last week on the impact of the Murphy administration’s policies and directives on nursing homes, veterans homes, and long-term care facilities.

Commissioner Persichilli and other members of the administration declined an invitation to attend the March 5 hearing or to answer the questions of legislators and family members.

“We need a select committee with subpoena power to compel Governor Murphy’s team to testify under oath since they won’t voluntarily appear before the Legislature to answer important questions,” Pennacchio said. “Families who lost loved ones deserve to know why the Murphy administration ignored all of the warnings. How much more evidence will Trenton Democrats need before they stop blocking this important investigation?”

Senate Democrats have repeatedly blocked Pennacchio efforts to advance SR-68, a resolution creating a bipartisan select committee with subpoena power to review the Murphy Administration’s pandemic response efforts. Motions by Pennacchio to bring the resolution up for a vote were blocked by the Democratic majority on three separate occasions.

Jay Edwards

Born and raised in Northwest NJ, Jay has a degree in Communications and has had a life-long interest in local radio and various styles of music. Jay has held numerous jobs over the years such as stunt car driver, bartender, voice-over artist, traffic reporter (award winning), NY Yankee maintenance crewmember and peanut farm worker. His hobbies include mountain climbing, snowmobiling, cooking, performing stand-up comedy and he is an avid squirrel watcher. Jay has been a guest on America’s Morning Headquarters,program on The Weather Channel, and was interviewed by Sam Champion.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button